Area Guide

What to do, where to eat, and what to skip, from people who live here, checked summer 2026.

This is the list we give everyone. It is longer than it needs to be, because I am the sort of person who reads up before visiting somewhere so as not to miss anything, and this is what I would want handed to me. It is written from the perspective of people who live here rather than people passing through, so there are things on it a tourist guide would never mention, and a few famous things we will tell you to skip.

Two notes. Everything is listed with its town and state, because "Mystic and the surrounding area" quietly spans two of them and a good number of these are in Rhode Island. And the restaurant scene here changes constantly · this list was checked over in the summer of 2026, but call ahead before you drive somewhere.

The island itself

As our guests you have the run of Masons Island, and it is one of the real pleasures of staying here. The roads carry very little traffic, which makes them ideal for running and cycling, and there are several public access points to the water. The one exception is the gates marked Private Drive below our house · that land is separately owned.

There is a guard at the gate in season. Tell him you are staying at 26 Schoolhouse. He will ask each time; that is simply how the gate works.

Farm stands and markets

  • B.F. Clyde's Cider Mill · 129 North Stonington Road, Old Mystic, CT. Seasonal: they open on the 1st of September and run into December. If you find them listed as "temporarily closed" in summer, that is just the off-season. They have cider donuts and all kinds of New England food products. They also have an interesting gift shop with New England crafts and some sort of wine bar. They make their own apple wines and hard ciders, with tastings. Phone: (860) 536-3354
  • Coventry Farmers' Market · 2299 South Street, Coventry, CT, at the Nathan Hale Homestead. Sundays, from late May through October. Still the largest farmers' market in the state, but it is a proper trip from here. It is a country fair atmosphere.
  • Denison Farmers Market · 120 Pequotsepos Road, Mystic, CT. Sundays, June through October, at the Denison Homestead. Local produce, church pies, seafood, some crafts, and a banjo player make this a true New England farmers market. Phone: (860) 536-9248
  • Stone Acres Farm · 393 North Main Street, Stonington, CT. Farmstand open daily with seasonal vegetables, pasture-raised meat, eggs and pantry staples. They have added a food truck since we first wrote this.
  • Stonington Farmers Market · 22 Bayview Avenue, Stonington, CT, at the Velvet Mill. Saturday mornings, and now indoors and year-round rather than seasonal. Cato Corner Farm sells their cheese here. Saturdays 9 to noon: outdoors behind the mill from Memorial Day into mid-October, then indoors for the colder months. This market has about 30 vendors selling produce, seafood, cheese, honey, maple syrup, bread, hummus, the famous sea coast mushrooms, some crafts, and more. A good chance to see the rest of the Velvet Mill Dogs are welcome, except where prepared food is sold.
  • The Velvet Mill · 22 Bayview Avenue, Stonington, CT. Worth a wander any day of the week, not just market day: art shops, galleries, antiques, a brewery, and several places to eat. A must destination for food, shops and working artists. Each shop and studio keeps its own hours.
  • Wehpittituck Farm · Cove Road, Stonington, CT. Fresh eggs, produce, and pure beauty. This is a huge photo opportunity: miles of stone walls, old buildings and farm animals. Honour-system payment. Our favourite of the lot, and only minutes from the house. They have donkeys, chickens, and sometimes cows. You are allowed to walk up the lane to see the animals.
June at the Stonington Farmers Market.

Shopping

  • Clinton Premium Outlets · Clinton, CT.
  • Downtown Mystic · Mystic, CT. Eighty-odd independent shops around the drawbridge. Lovely, and very crowded in season; we tend to avoid it in July and August.
  • Jonnycake Center of Westerly · 23 Industrial Drive, Westerly, RI. The granddaddy of thrift stores: filled with great stuff, but well organised. I have found great dishware here. There can be a line at busy times, so a quiet weekday is best. It is a non-profit, and its programmes include a food pantry. Park in the public lot across Industrial Drive. Phone: (401) 377-8069
  • Manufaktura · Mystic, CT, in Olde Mistick Village; also Watch Hill, RI. Beautiful Polish pottery.
  • Mine · 40 Washington Street, Mystic, CT. Antiques, local art, and a genuine treasure hunt; our dining room table came from there and the owners are wonderful. Glassware, old tools, Gemstones, handcrafted wooden fish, vintage clothing, old record albums, are among some of the items found here. You never know what treasure you will find, but always great. Mike and Lyndsey have become friends over the years. Say hi for us. There is off-street parking.
  • Olde Mistick Village · 27 Coogan Boulevard, Mystic, CT. Shops and eateries with nice walking paths. You can get a bite or just walk around and watch the ducks. Good for children · try the chocolate-covered bananas. There are kitchen shops, Scandinavian, Naples and Japanese stores, toy shops, children's clothing, jewelry stores, T-shirt shops, a boat, and about a dozen places to dine. They have festivals several times a year featuring art, food, etc. Check to see what is happening while you are visiting. Phone: (860) 536-4941
  • Pennywise · 22 Greenmanville Avenue, Mystic, CT. High-end consignment, mostly clothing, handbags and jewellery. Open seven days. Our daughter has found cute things here. Phone: (860) 572-9232
  • The Fun Company · Westerly, RI. A bit of everything, inventory constantly changing, designer overstock at wholesale prices: clothing, linens, toys, home goods. Stationery, local logo clothing. Their pricing is incredible at 75% off what you would find at a local boutique. They also own the adjoining store, The Vault, with higher-end labels. Highly recommended.
  • Water Street, Stonington Borough · Stonington Borough, CT. Mostly antiques, a few clothing shops, and some good restaurants. Noah's and Milagro are both along it.
  • Westerly · Westerly, RI. About ten miles away, with far more restaurants and shops than you would expect, a really nice park, a theatre, and music performances. Much more accessible than Mystic in summer. All the big-box stores are out along Route 1 · thankfully, Mystic has none.
  • Antique shops abound in the area. I am not too versed in them, as I am at the age where I am getting rid of stuff instead of accumulating it.

On the water

The tour boats and sailing charters that pass our house, where to rent kayaks and paddleboards, and the fishing charters we know. We have kayak stands by the back door, and guests have paddled rented kayaks up to our dock.

Boats, kayaks and fishing →

Tours and attractions

  • Denison Homestead · 120 Pequotsepos Road, Mystic, CT. Established in 1654. You can walk the grounds and hiking trails freely, but house tours run only three weekdays plus Saturdays in season, so check before you set out. Fascinating to be in such an old house. A little creepy, but said to be haunted. Park across the street at the nature center. Phone: (860) 536-9248
  • Mystic Aquarium · 55 Coogan Boulevard, Mystic, CT. Among the best in the country, and a non-profit with a serious research programme. Open daily. Phone: (860) 572-5955
  • Mystic Seaport Museum · 75 Greenmanville Avenue, Mystic, CT. The nation's leading maritime museum, founded in 1929 to gather and preserve the artefacts of America's seafaring past. Go early in the morning on a day that is not too hot. Fascinating and exhausting in equal measure. It is not open every day in the off-season, so check the website before you go. Phone: (860) 572-0711
  • Seaside Shadows · Mystic, CT. Haunted history tours of the town and the cemeteries. Book ahead. The downtown tour is the best of them and you will want walking shoes. They were just named one of the top 10 ghost tours in the country. They recommend it for ages 11 and up. It is more a history tour of the area. You learn about the good and the bad. Commander John Mason, the namesake of our island, ordered the Mystic Massacre, killing over 400 Pequot natives, after one of his soldiers was killed. Many perished in a purposely set fire on the land near the drawbridge. Since then, downtown Mystic has been plagued by many unexplained fires. This tour presents so much history. I have done this tour about 7 times with visitors and never tire of it.
  • Whitehall Cemetery · Mystic, CT. Even if you skip the night-time ghost tour, this is a very old burying ground worth seeing. It has a stone body cellar where the dead were kept until the ground thawed, and it is tangled up in a great many ghost stories, including a lost native burial site and a vampire burial. It sits on the Whitehall Mansion grounds · ask at the inn about visiting.

Day trips

  • Block Island · Block Island, RI. A full day, possibly overnight. The ferry runs from Point Judith in Narragansett, about an hour's drive, and takes thirty minutes on the fast boat or fifty-five on the traditional one. Bring bikes or hire a car and tour; some locals will take you round in their own. Beautiful lighthouse, a great deal of history, good shopping and restaurants.
  • Chester Hadlyme car ferry · Ferry Road, Chester, CT. Operates April 1st to November 30th. This ferry has run continuously since 1769. This is a fun way to visit the quaint town of Chester after your visit to Gillette Castle. It is about a 5-minute trip across the river. Again, a kid's dream. Phone: (860) 594-2560
  • Chester, Connecticut · Chester, CT. Chester is small, but has all kinds of shops with craftsmen's products and many places to dine. This is where the River Tavern is located. There is a waterfall in the middle of town. I think it is more picturesque than Mystic, but lacks the waterscape. There is a great dress store named Lark in a stone building on Water Street.
  • Essex Steam Train & Riverboat · 1 Railroad Avenue, Essex, CT, about forty minutes. A train ride and a boat ride in one afternoon. Reservations required; seasonal, roughly May through October. Phone: (860) 767-0103
  • Galilee and Point Judith · Narragansett, RI, about an hour. Bring a cooler to buy seafood, or have lunch at Champlin's Seafood Deck overlooking the harbour and watch the fishing boats and the gulls. The Block Island ferry leaves from here.
  • Gillette Castle State Park · East Haddam, CT. 200 feet above the Connecticut River, this medieval mansion was gifted to Connecticut by the actor William Gillette. It looks like a crumbling castle. It is well worth the approximately 1-hour trip to go there. Castle tour tickets are limited, so book ahead. Phone: (860) 526-2336
  • Newport · Newport, RI, about an hour. Where the Vanderbilts, Rockefellers and the rest of the Gilded Age elite built their summer houses, most of which you can now tour. Our favourites are The Breakers and Marble House. If you want the view from below stairs, the Servant Life Tour runs at The Elms.
  • Ninigret Park · Charlestown, RI. A big playground, and two giant wooden trolls by the famous Danish artist Thomas Dambo, Erik Rock and Greta Granit. Park by the Frosty Drew Observatory for Erik, then follow the clues to Greta. Set your GPS to Ninigret Park, not Fort Ninigret, which is a separate historic site.
  • The Cliff Walk · Newport, RI. A three-and-a-half-mile public path along the shoreline, running behind the back lawns of the mansions with enormous ocean views the whole way. Note that this is not the same thing as Rosecliff, which is one of the houses you tour. One section of the Walk is closed for storm repairs with a signed detour, so check the City of Newport's site before you go. One stretch, between Narragansett Avenue and Webster Street, is closed for the foreseeable future; the rest is open.
  • The Fantastic Umbrella Factory · 4820 Old Post Road, Charlestown, RI, near Watch Hill. A quirky collection of hippy and art shops with beautiful gardens, chickens running loose, an emu called George, and some goats who have arrived to keep him company. Children love it, as do I. A good stop to pair with Ninigret Park. No dogs on the property. Phone: (401) 364-1060
  • Watch Hill · Westerly, RI, about thirty minutes. Taylor Swift's house is here, and the public beach below it is lovely and rarely crowded · the entrances are on Bluff Avenue and a couple of the side streets. You can walk out to the lighthouse, though the tower itself is closed and the road up is walking-only. Taylor's song "The Last Great American Dynasty" is about the history of that house. Parking in the village is genuinely difficult in season; read the practical notes at the end before you drive over.
  • Wickford · North Kingstown, RI. A quaint, very old seaside village, ideal for walking, with good restaurants and shopping. Much of the artwork in our house came from Harbor View Artisans on Brown Street, a co-op of local artists, where the work is wonderful and the prices are reasonable. The town has a tidal river that rushes in and out in minutes. It's amazing to witness. The Witches of Eastwick was filmed at the church here. The Wickford Art Festival · around two hundred juried artists at Wilson Park · runs in July and is worth planning a day around.

Food

Bakeries and coffee, casual places, clam shacks, upscale dinners, wine and beer, cheese, ice cream and butchers, from people who live here. We stay away from downtown Mystic in summer because of the waits, and mostly cook at home.

Where we eat →

Walking, running, hiking and biking

Walks, runs, hikes and rides from the front door outward: Masons Island itself, Enders Island, Barn Island, Bluff Point, Noank village and more, with parking and tide notes.

Walks, hikes and rides →

Casinos

  • Foxwoods Resort Casino · 350 Trolley Line Boulevard, Mashantucket, CT, about eight miles. The largest self-contained casino in the United States. We are not remotely casino people, but it is worth seeing for the architecture alone, and there are dozens of restaurants, outlet stores, and top names performing every evening; look into events several months ahead, because they sell out. My favourite thing there is the Chinese bakery, which rivals anything in Chinatown in New York or San Francisco. We also had dinner at Hell's Kitchen. Fun to see the performance and cooking, and the prime rib was excellent. Phone: (800) 369-9663
  • Mashantucket Pequot Museum · Mashantucket, CT. Highly rated and well worth the time, but it is a separate building a short drive from the casino and it opens only Wednesday to Saturday. Its observation tower is currently closed. Check their site before you set out.
  • Mohegan Sun · 1 Mohegan Sun Boulevard, Uncasville, CT. A second casino, smaller than Foxwoods. The decor is beautiful. the restaurant choices are different from Foxwoods. The famous New Haven pizzas are featured.

On our list, not tried yet

Recommended by people we trust, but we cannot vouch for them ourselves.

  • The Irons Restaurant · 20 Coogan Boulevard, Mystic, CT. outdoor seating, reasonable pricing, serves breakfast and dinner only, casual. Recommended, but we haven't been there yet. Phone: (860) 572-0731
  • Via Emilia · 24 West Main Street, Mystic, CT. Emilia-Romagna cooking with house-made pasta; consistently among the best-rated in town. Very good experience, it just got a national award Phone: (860) 415-4840
  • Wickford Art Association · 36 Beach Street, Wickford, RI. A non-profit gallery running since 1962, with classes and an open studio most Thursdays. Phone: (401) 294-6840

Before you go: the practical bits

These are the things that catch people out, and none of them are obvious.

  • Out-of-state cars pay to park at Connecticut state parks. Bluff Point and Harkness are free for Connecticut plates but charge everyone else, more at weekends and on holidays. If you are here for a week and plan several visits, the out-of-state season pass may work out cheaper.
  • Watch Hill parking is the most expensive surprise on this list. There is no parking at Napatree Point at all. On-street parking on Bay Street is free but time-limited in summer; the Bay Street lot explicitly forbids beach parking; and the Larkin lot is free for thirty minutes and then a flat fee that will startle you. There is no overnight parking anywhere in the village.
  • Dogs: allowed at Coogan Farm and Paffard Woods, not on the Nature Center trails, and restricted at Napatree during the day in nesting season.
  • Ticks are present everywhere here. Check yourself, your children and your dogs after any walk.
  • The clam shacks close for winter, as do Buttonwood Farm, most of the boat tours, and Clyde's Cider Mill in reverse; it opens in September.
  • Call ahead. Everything in this list was checked over in the summer of 2026, but restaurants here open, close and change hands constantly. A two-minute phone call saves a wasted drive.

Come stay with us

Book direct with the owners: no platform fees, and we answer every inquiry ourselves, usually within a day.

Check rates & availability Send an inquiry

Check availability